P&H: Validated Distance Education Engineering Degrees Cannot Bar Future Promotion

punjab-haryana
⚖️ Order Date: 22 Sep 2026
Headnotes

Writ — Locus standi — Petitioners challenging consideration of senior officers for promotion to Executive Engineer, while themselves junior to those officers and lacking requisite eight years' experience as Sub-Divisional Engineer — Petitioners not within the zone of consideration and unable to establish locus to...

Haryana Development and Panchayats Department (Group B) Service Rules, 2016, R.9(1)(a)(ii) — Promotion to Sub-Divisional Engineer — Private respondents promoted under diploma-holder category, for which an engineering degree was not required — Challenge to their initial promotion on ground that their engineering degrees were obtained...

Service — Promotion — Petitioners challenged promotion of private respondents to Executive Engineer on ground that their distance education engineering degrees were invalid -- Upon passing AICTE test, degrees stood revived, and restriction on “no additional benefit” barred only retrospective benefits, not future promotions --...


Facts of the Case

P&H: Validated Distance Education Engineering Degrees Cannot Bar Future Promotion

The Punjab and Haryana High Court has dismissed a petition challenging the proposed promotion of Haryana government employees who obtained engineering degrees through distance education between 2001 and 2005. Justice Nidhi Gupta held that once the degrees were validated after the candidates cleared the AICTE examination, the employees could be considered for future service benefits, including promotion.

The petitioners, who were working as Sub-Divisional Engineers, argued that the private respondents were not eligible for promotion to the post of Executive Engineer. They relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in Orissa Lift Irrigation Corporation Ltd. v. Rabi Shankar Patro, under which...

Login required to open full judgment PDF
Login to Access File