P&H: Rejects Clerk’s Claim for Earlier Promotion Based on Exam Date

punjab-haryana
⚖️ Order Date: 04 Nov 2026
Headnotes

(i) Punjab Treasuries (State Services Class-III) Rules, 1979, R.8(1) — Promotion — Passing Assistant Grade Examination was not, by itself, sufficient for promotion — Five years’ experience in feeder post was also prescribed as a condition of eligibility, and rule further required inter-se seniority to...

(ii) Punjab Treasuries (State Services Class-III) Rules, 1979, R.8(1) — Promotion — Petitioner had not completed prescribed five years experience and could not claim vacancy merely on basis of having passed examination — Petitioner claim, if otherwise admissible, could arise only upon his becoming eligible...

(iii) Punjab Treasuries (State Services Class-III) Rules, 1979, R.8 — Promotion — Date of passing examination cannot be treated as the sole criterion for determining the order of promotion. (Para 11)


Facts of the Case

P&H: Rejects Clerk’s Claim for Earlier Promotion Based on Exam Date

The Punjab and Haryana High Court has dismissed a Treasury Department clerk’s petition seeking promotion benefits from the date a colleague who passed the Assistant Grade Examination after him was promoted.

Justice Sandeep Moudgil held that passing the examination alone did not make the petitioner eligible for promotion. Under the applicable service rules, he also needed five years’ experience in the feeder post.

The petitioner, Ashwani Kumar, joined the Treasury Department as a clerk on August 26, 1986, and passed the examination on June 8, 1990. He was promoted as Senior Assistant only in 2011. He argued that he should...

Login required to open full judgment PDF
Login to Access File