P&H: Upholds Bar On Civil Suit Challenging Market Fee Recovery

punjab-haryana
⚖️ Order Date: 04 Nov 2026
Headnotes

(i) Punjab Land Revenue Act, 1887, S.158(2)(xiv) — Jurisdiction — Recovery of land revenue or in other words some recoverable as arrears of land revenue — Jurisdiction of Civil Court excluded. (Para 14)

(ii) Res judicata — Earlier writ petition challenging same demand dismissed — Plaintiff cannot reagitate matter by challenging same demand by filing suit for declaration being impliedly hit by principle of constructive res judicata. (Para 16)

(iii) Land Revenue — Recovery — Company — Change in management does not extinguish the demand where company’s constitution remains unchanged — The demand was raised qua company itself and even if there had been change in management in 1981, same by itself will not be sufficient...


Facts of the Case

P&H: Upholds Bar On Civil Suit Challenging Market Fee Recovery

The Punjab and Haryana High Court has dismissed a flour mill company’s second appeal challenging a demand for market fee dating back to 1969–70. Justice Sanjiv Berry held that the Civil Court could not hear the challenge because the demand was being pursued through recovery as arrears of land revenue.

M/s Amar Flour Mills Private Ltd had been asked to pay ₹83,349.30 in market fee and related amounts. The company sought a declaration that the demand was unlawful and a permanent injunction against its recovery.

The company said its management had changed in 1981 and that the previous management had...

Login required to open full judgment PDF
Login to Access File